header banner

when the former foreign minister of Israel "admitted" that Gaza was being punished collectively

Table of Contents

Danny Ayalon tells Al Jazeera that Palestinians in Gaza should move to Sinai in Egypt to seek relief from the ongoing fighting between Israel and Hamas.

Former Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon has told Al Jazeera that people in Gaza should evacuate their residences and relocate to the Sinai Desert in Egypt, where temporary tent cities could be established for them, amid the ongoing fighting between Israel and Hamas.

The interview has been shared widely on social media, with Ayalon receiving widespread criticism for his comments, which many said were a call for “ethnic cleansing”.

“We told the Gazan people to clear the area temporarily, so we can go and take Hamas out, and then, of course, they can come back,” said Ayalon, speaking to Marc Lamont Hill on an episode of UpFront that aired on Friday.

“We don’t tell Gazans to go to the beaches or drown themselves … No, God forbid … Go to the Sinai Desert. There is a huge expanse, almost endless space in the Sinai Desert just on the other side of Gaza.”

In my interview with a former Israeli deputy Foreign Minister, he acknowledged that Israel is collectively punishing the people of Gaza. pic.twitter.com/gZRiz9k3o4

— Marc Lamont Hill (@marclamonthill) October 14, 2023

“The idea is for them to leave over to the open areas where we and the international community will prepare infrastructure … tent cities, with food and with water, just like for the refugees of Syria,” Ayalon added.

Moreover, the former deputy foreign minister said everything will be “restored” in Gaza, if there is an “immediate surrender, unconditional surrender of Hamas”, which Lamont pointed out was a “textbook” definition of collective punishment.

On October 9, Israel announced a total blockade of the Gaza Strip, including the stoppage of fuel and gas deliveries, two days after fighters from Hamas carried out deadly attacks inside Israel.

The decision to cut basic supplies to Gaza, which has already been under an Israeli siege for 16 years, was condemned by the United Nations, which said it was an act of “collective punishment” and prohibited under international law.


“Danny Ayalon is actually advocating for ethnic cleansing in front of the global public, secure in the knowledge that there’s little to stop him in terms of international pressure or rebuke,” Marc Owen Jones, an associate professor at Hamad Bin Khalifa University in Qatar, posted on X, formerly known as Twitter.

Another user said that based on Ayalon’s remarks, Israel’s goal was seemingly the “repurposing of Gaza into settlements while banishing what remains of the local population into refugee camps in the desert”.

Others said Ayalon was calling for a second “Nakba” or “catastrophe”.

The “Nakba” refers to the ethnic cleansing of Palestine and the near-total destruction of Palestinian society in 1948. Zionist military forces expelled at least 750,000 Palestinians from their homes and lands and captured 78 percent of historic Palestine. The remaining 22 percent was divided into what are now the occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

Danny Ayalon, #Israeli former Deputy Foreign Minister, loudly and clearly calls for a second #Nakba and displacement of the Palestinians of #Gaza to Sinai #Egypt, same as the Syrians!#Israel is not defending itself, Israel is ethnically cleansing Gaza!


— Dr. Abdallah Marouf د. عبدالله معروف (@AbdallahMarouf) October 14, 2023

Lamont Hill also spoke on the episode with Osama Hamdan, a Hamas senior spokesperson. Hamdan avoided answering questions about whether the killing of Israeli civilians was justified, and instead referred back to the ongoing occupation of the Palestinian people.

Speaking about Hamas’s attack on October 7, Hamdan said: “The Israelis were shocked, these [were] the main troops attacking Gaza for the last 10 years … They want to get back the image of the Israeli army.”

In the first seven days of the war, approximately one million residents of Gaza have been forced to leave their homes, as reported by the United Nations agency assisting Palestinian refugees. Humanitarian organisations have described the conditions in the besieged coastal enclave as “dire” or “catastrophic”.

Israeli air attacks have claimed the lives of more than 2,329 Palestinians, with 724 of them being children. Meanwhile, more than 1,300 Israelis, including 286 soldiers, have been killed.


Article information

Author: Alice Smith

Last Updated: 1704092522

Views: 1227

Rating: 3.8 / 5 (104 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Alice Smith

Birthday: 1984-05-30

Address: 21273 Felicia Trace Apt. 024, North Brianland, CT 00563

Phone: +3811378550574712

Job: Cryptocurrency Analyst

Hobby: Origami, Basketball, DIY Electronics, Survival Skills, Stamp Collecting, Puzzle Solving, Wine Tasting

Introduction: My name is Alice Smith, I am a audacious, esteemed, brilliant, persistent, fearless, strong-willed, candid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.